Bentleigh station isn’t finished

Now that we’ve finished talking about names of yet-to-be-built stations, let’s talk about some recently built ones.

Last Saturday a steam train ran to celebrate a year (and a bit) since the new Bentleigh/McKinnon/Ormond stations re-opened, following level crossing removals.

But while they’ve now been in use for well over a year, the stations aren’t actually finished.

Even leaving aside the controversial Ormond tower, there are numerous little things that haven’t been completed.

The bike cages at Ormond and McKinnon seem to be in use (after some delays), but the one at Bentleigh is suspiciously empty, leading me to believe the issues with its construction are still not resolved — though Bentleigh is listed on the Parkiteer web site.
Bike cage at Bentleigh station

The retail space at Bentleigh and McKinnon hasn’t been leased… it hasn’t even been fitted out! I’m told this is in VicTracks’ hands. This should be a prime location. How much revenue (that could offset the project cost) has been foregone? (Ormond doesn’t have such a space.)
McKinnon station retail space
Retail space at Bentleigh station

The Smartbus signs at Bentleigh still aren’t operational. The eastbound sign hasn’t been fully working since 2011 when the train departure times were switched off. It was removed completely for the level crossing removals, and then put back — but now even the bus times are displayed at present. Its smaller twin (with space for bus times only) for westbound buses doesn’t work either.
Bentleigh station Smartbus sign, not working

The small picnic area between Bentleigh and McKinnon appeared to be completed, and was looking nice, until recently when someone took away the benches. Only the rubbish bin has been left. It’s not clear why, nor if it’s permanent.
Small recreation area between Bentleigh and McKinnon stations

Also of note: some pretty sloppy work that has left drainage problems on platform 3 at Bentleigh…
Bentleigh station platform 3

…and on the south-east side of the bridge.
Footpath opposite Bentleigh station

This is just what I’ve noticed when using the stations. There seems to be a steady stream of workers still doing little jobs — is it maintenance, or are there other things not completed?

The achievements of the level crossing removal project — a massive upgrade that has benefited motorists, pedestrians, cyclists, public transport users alike — are to be celebrated.

But with dozens of similar projects underway around Melbourne, it seems to me they need to get better at ensuring everything gets finished so they can draw a line under it and move on.

Update 6/12/2017:

I noticed another thing: despite me asking Metro about it multiple times, the signage at Patterson advising which trains use which platforms at which times, removed during the project, still hasn’t been replaced:

Patterson station entrance

And: Liberal Bentleigh candidate Asher Judah has posted this on Twitter, about the Smartbus sign:

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment. You can subscribe via feed reader RSS, or subscribe by email. You can also Follow me on Twitter, or Like the blog on Facebook.

8 Replies to “Bentleigh station isn’t finished”

  1. Yes, small things, but annoying!
    It would be interesting to look at the building contracts to see if everyone has already been paid so there is no incentive to finish things off properly.

  2. The new Gardiner station was operational nearly two years ago. The adjacent reserve / sports oval which was used as a building site during this time has still not been returned to its original condition, with temporary fencing surrounding a vast expanse of dirt. Only in the last month or two does it appear that some progress is being made.

  3. I bet those leased shop spaces are too expensive. The one at Ringwood is still empty, and the one at Mitcham now has a tenant again after being occupied for a few months, then empty for over a year. It should be possible to run a profitable coffee shop at a station, so I suspect the rent is too high to make it viable.

  4. Sounds exactly like any project, eg . IT or renovations (in my experience), those last few things are near impossible to get finished!

  5. Reminds me that it seemed like ages for the announcements to be audible at the new West Footscray station. And I think it was only recently that the black tape on the wayfinding sign for the lift was taken off.

    Just a comment on Parkiteer cages – would be good if they had soft-closing gates, so that you didn’t have to juggle the bike and the gate at the same time to avoid it slamming.

  6. Iโ€™m not convinced that North Melbourne Station is finished yet either, as the ugly undercroft of the new station building remains exposed and looks like a construction site. Surely this is supposed to be cladded in some way? Thereโ€™s also a pretty ugly and out-of-place tin fence along the western platform screening the rail yards, which looks out-of-place.

  7. Don’t forget the patchy mobile coverage – particularly at Ormond – through the whole 3 stations. So sick of hearing “hello, hello, can you hear me?” as we travel through the new stations. Surely this should have been part of the project!

  8. @Nick, the sports oval is probably meant to be done by the council. I know it was the case with the Gunn Reserve in Ormond, which was used for construction.

    @Rachael, yeah I find phone coverage is really patchy, especially between Ormond station and about halfway to Glenhuntly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.